If a pitcher exceeds his allowable pitch count during a no-hitter, what does the umpire rule?

The correct response is that the pitcher must finish facing the current batter if he exceeds his allowable pitch count. This rule recognizes that baseball often involves the flow and strategy of the game, and it allows for a smooth transition between players while maintaining the integrity of the game. The pitcher is granted the courtesy of completing the confrontation with the current batter, which is in line with the spirit of fair play and sportsmanship.

Once the at-bat is completed, the coach must then replace the pitcher in accordance with the rules governing pitch counts. This ensures that safety and health considerations for the players are prioritized, which is a central tenet of the NFHS rules. Allowing the pitcher to finish against the batter helps prevent potential disruption in the game as a result of an abrupt substitution.